| Colby | Daniel | Matthew | Alex | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AFC North | Pittsburgh Steelers | Pittsburgh Steelers | Pittsburgh Steelers | Baltimore Ravens |
| AFC East | New England Patriots | Miami Dolphins | New England Patriots | New England Patriots |
| AFC South | Indianapolis Colts | Indianapolis Colts | Indianapolis Colts | Indianapolis Colts |
| AFC West | San Diego Chargers | San Diego Chargers | Denver Broncos | Denver Broncos |
| AFC Wild Card | Denver Broncos | New England Patriots | Buffalo Bills | San Diego Chargers |
| AFC Wild Card | Baltimore Ravens | Cincinnati Bengals | Cincinnati Bengals | Pittsburgh Steelers |
| NFC North | Green Bay Packers | Detroit Lions | Green Bay Packers | Green Bay Packers |
| NFC East | Dallas Cowboys | Philadelphia Eagles | Philadelphia Eagles | Philadelphia Eagles |
| NFC South | Atlanta Falcons | Atlanta Falcons | New Orleans Saints | Atlanta Falcons |
| NFC West | Seattle Seahawks | Seattle Seahawks | Seattle Seahawks | Arizona Cardinals |
| NFC Wild Card | Arizona Cardinals | Minnesota Vikings | New York Giants | Seattle Seahawks |
| NFC Wild Card | Minnesota Vikings | Green Bay Packers | Arizona Cardinals | Chicago Bears |
| AFC Champ | Indianapolis Colts | Indianapolis Colts | Denver Broncos | Indianapolis Colts |
| NFC Champ | Dallas Cowboys | Green Bay Packers | Seattle Seahawks | Philadelphia Eagles |
| Super Bowl Champ | Indianapolis Colts | Indianapolis Colts | Seattle Seahawks | Philadelphia Eagles |
| MVP | Aaron Rodgers, GB | Andrew Luck, IND | Tom Brady, NE | Andrew Luck, IND |
| Offensive POY | Le'Veon Bell, PIT | Dez Bryant, DAL | Tom Brady, NE | Julio Jones, ATL |
| Defensive POY | J.J. Watt, HOU | Robert Quinn, STL | Quinton Coples, NYJ | Luke Kuechly, CAR |
| Offensive ROY | Devin Funchess, CAR | Tevin Coleman, ATL | Melvin Gordon, SD | Melvin Gordon, SD |
| Defensive ROY | Danny Shelton, CLE | Hau'Oli Kikaha, NO | Landon Collins, NYG | Vic Beasley, ATL |
| Comeback POY | Victor Cruz, NYG | Eric Berry, KC | Victor Cruz, NYG | Sam Bradford, PHI |
| Coach of the Year | Mike McCoy, SD | Mike McCoy, SD | Todd Bowles, NYJ | Chip Kelly, PHI |
